Article Highlight: Quincy Newell on Jane Manning James

By January 16, 2014

Occasionally, I do a keyword search for “Mormon” in JSTOR and Project Muse to see if anything comes up.  A few days ago, I got a hit for a journal article that I didn’t know had been published or was even in the works. Quincy Newell, a religious studies professor at the University of Wyoming, has an article in the Journal of Africana Religions about Jane Manning James. Newell’s article is meant to showcase two significant documents: the autobiography that James dictated to Elizabeth Roundy around 1902 and the James’ reminiscences about the Prophet Joseph Smith that the Young Woman’s Journal published in December 1905. Although the focus of Newell’s article is on the documents, the short biography and analysis that she provides of James’ life is compelling. Newell situates the rumors her son Sylvester was the child of white man within the “naturalized sexual violence” to which black women were subject throughout the nineteenth century. She reminds us that it is impossible to know whether the relationship was consensual and that the existence of a biracial child born out of wedlock would have confirmed in the minds of many white, middle class men and women that the idea that black women like James were sexually promiscuous. The possibility that James had not consented to the relationship would not have made her any less culpable in the eyes of many white men and women. Newell also discusses James’ relationship to black religion, pointing out her conversion narrative does not mirror that of other black men and women in the nineteenth century. Overall, Newell’s article is fascinating and anyone interested in the history of race within Mormonism should check it out.


Citation: Quincy Newell, “The Autobiography and Interview of Jane Elizabeth Manning James,” Journal of Africana Religions Vol. 1, No. 2 (2013): 251 – 270.

Article filed under Miscellaneous


  1. You kind of made that article hard to find. The exact citation is
    Quincy D. Newell, “The Autobiography and Interview of Jane Elizabeth Manning James,” Journal of Africana Religions Vol. 1, No. 2 (2013), pp. 251-291

    Comment by Niklas — January 16, 2014 @ 8:08 am

  2. Sorry for the mistake. I’ll fix the citation. I blame the fact I wrote the citation while nursing a baby at 5 a.m.

    Comment by Amanda — January 16, 2014 @ 9:40 am

  3. Thanks, Amanda. I’m excited to read this.

    Comment by Christopher — January 16, 2014 @ 10:21 am

  4. Thanks for the shout-out, Amanda! I came to the JI today after quite a hiatus–it was a fun surprise to see my name (?!?) at the top of the page. I figured those documents were fairly well-known within the Mormon Studies community, but I really wanted to bring Jane James to the attention of those who study African American religion.

    Comment by Quincy D. Newell — January 16, 2014 @ 7:41 pm

  5. What on earth? I just looked on Wiki and found out that church leaders sealed Sis. James up as an eternal servant. How revolting and racist.

    Comment by Jessica — February 10, 2014 @ 6:12 pm


Recent Comments

Steve Fleming on Inclusive Monotheism and Joseph: “Alchemy and Neoplatonism often overlapped, but I agree, JS's language looks very similar to the Timaeus in those quotes. And I'm happy to hear…”

Jacob H. on Inclusive Monotheism and Joseph: “Earlier, I had assumed Joseph's language was drawing on alchemical roots. But it is hard to find references that fit as well as the Timaeus.…”

Steve Fleming on Inclusive Monotheism and Joseph: “And Taylor's translation also says, "The composition of the world, therefore, received one whole of each of these four natures. For its composing artificer constituted…”

Steve Fleming on Inclusive Monotheism and Joseph: “In terms of the similarities between the Timaeus and JS's statment regarding creation out of existing matter, Thomas Taylor's translation said, "But since it is…”

Clark on Inclusive Monotheism and Joseph: “Like I've said, the idea of a pantheon is common in the near east and related regions including Greece and Rome. It's just not that…”

Juvenile Instructor » Inclusive Monotheism and Joseph Smith’s Sermon at the Grove on Isaac Newton's Inclusive Monotheism: “[…] Gods and that our God was the one who created our solar system. Franklin was probably influenced by Isaac Newton who also said there…”