Under Glass at D.I.: How I Found a Rare Copy of The World’s Fair Ecclesiastical History of Utah

By September 23, 2013

To historians, collectors, and aficionados of 19th-century America, it is no surprise that the Chicago World’s Columbian Exposition, or Chicago World’s Fair of 1893 is highly popular for its abundance of collectible items still in circulation among antique dealers, collectors’ sites, and Ebay, of course. Indeed, a cursory search of “Chicago World’s Fair 1893” on Ebay brings up hundreds of items, from paper weights, silk scarves, plates, bowls, medallions, shaving cups, lamps, bookmarks, coins, spoons, Fair tickets, and every variation of printed and photographic material imaginable.  One could literally lose fortune, space, and sanity to build a personal collection of World’s Fair memorabilia.  As a historian of women’s—and particularly Mormon women’s—participation at the Chicago World’s Fair, I am constantly on the lookout for printed items from the Fair, but especially those related to the involvement of western women, Mormon women, the Relief Society, and Utah, Idaho, Montana, or other western and Midwestern states in general. While there are dozens of “official” Fair publications, guidebooks and photographic tours of the Fair, most states also published their own “official” state book.

My first acquisitions of World’s Fair books were the publications from the World’s Congress of Representative Women, held as part of the pre-Fair congresses and the official meetings of the National Council of Women.  DSC_0886The WCRW was the most significant gathering of suffragists, educators, religionists, feminists, and other national and international female contributors to society, culture, reform, and politics up to that point.  Sponsored by the Board of Lady Managers and under the presidential leadership of Bertha Palmer, who was the wife of Chicago’s hotel magnate, Potter Palmer, literally hundreds of women participated in the Congress, including such legendary figures as Susan B. Anthony, May Wright Sewall, and Rachel Foster Avery. Mormon women were invited to the World’s Congress, especially since the Relief Society and Young Ladies’ Mutual Improvement Association had been affiliated with the NCW since 1888. The Congress of Women (Philadelphia and Chicago: S.I. Bell & Co., 1894), was the official publication released by the Board of Lady Managers in 1894.  DSC_0887In the last six years, I have acquired two copies of this, and of particular interest to me was the speech by a Mormon suffragist, Mrs. Electa Bullock– the one Mormon who actually made it into the publication– who wrote on the status and progress of “Industrial Women.”  The book also includes photographs of Utah’s two representatives to the Board of Lady Managers, Mrs. Margaret Salisbury and Mrs. Thomas A. Whalen.

A second publication from the congress is The World’s Congress of Representative Women, edited by May Wright Sewall, and published in 1894 as a collection of the best speeches given at the Congress between May 15 and May 22, 1893 by American and international women.  This volume is even more rich with Mormon and Relief Society material, with speeches by Zina D.H. Young, Ellis R. Shipp, Emmeline B. Wells, and Emily S. Richards included, as well as photographic images of Young, Wells, and Richards.   I was able to use Emily Richards’s speech as part of my forthcoming biography and documents in Deseret Book’s Women of Faith series, volume III.DSC_0893 

While these larger tomes on the overall fair and World’s Congress are perhaps a little more common, the individual state publications are much more challenging to find.  I first acquired the state books of Kansas and Iowa for my personal library, and while I still don’t have Montana’s and Idaho’s World’s Fair publications, I have held them in my hand at their respective state historical societies. I also found and photocopied Utah’s book at the Utah State University Archives and Special Collections in Logan.  After years of keeping an eye open for a copy, I was finally able to purchase one from a rare and used bookseller at the Mormon History Association book display in Layton, Utah in June 2013.DSC_0892

This post is not meant to be a self-congratulatory catalog of my rare books.  Indeed, I am not the most committed or prolific collector of Mormon or World’s Fair books.   My collection is in its infancy, and most of what I’ve found has been by accident, or from being in the right place at the right time on Ebay.  

Which is partly what makes my next find so remarkable and memorable to me, and worth sharing here at Juvenile Instructor, in connection with this month’s theme about material culture.   As part of Mormon women’s preparations for the Chicago World’s Fair—both at the pre-Fair Congress of Women, as well as for Utah’s displays in the Women’s Building and the Utah Building, Utah’s women leaders commissioned the publication of various books and pamphlets for distribution among fair visitors. Indeed, these state publications certainly fell in line with the larger motives of boosterism, of recruiting new residents to western states, and of promoting regional economic development.  But Utah’s women, and especially Relief Society leaders, had the added motive of showcasing a positive public image of Mormon women as progressive and patriotic suffragists, while also attempting to counter the common stereotype of duped and oppressed polygamist wives.  To that end, Utah’s women leaders commissioned three books:  Songs and Flowers of the Wasatch and Charities and Philanthropies of Utah were both compiled and edited by Emmeline B. Wells, and meant to highlight the cultural and religious contributions of Mormon and non-Mormon Utah women.   The third, The World’s Fair Ecclesiastical History of Utah, was compiled by an interfaith committee headed up by famed Mormon Relief Society and suffrage leader, Sarah Melissa Granger Kimball.  All three books are incredibly rare and valuable, not just monetarily, but as part of the rich story of Mormon women’s organizing efforts at the Chicago World’s Fair. 

Imagine my surprise one Saturday when I took my children to Rexburg’s own Deseret Industries store on a routine run-through for whatever we might find there.  (For our non-LDS readers, this is a consignment store of locally-donated items meant to help raise money for church humanitarian efforts, while also giving employment opportunities to local youth).   We usually go straight to the famous D.I. locked glass case, to examine the treasures there.  (The “locked case” is where specialty, collectible, antique, and other more valuable items are kept.)  Lying on a top shelf was a copy of The World’s Fair Ecclesiastical History of Utah—right here in River City.DSC_0889  Excitedly, I called a store attendant to pull the book for closer examination.  When I opened it, I found inside an inscription addressed to a Mrs. M.A. Wallace, dated June 1893, and signed by Jane S. Richards—THE  Jane S. Richards. (And this is the cue for my dozen or so colleague-historians of Mormon women, who actually know who she is, to be duly impressed.  I myself got visibly emotional right there on the spot. The poor store attendant didn’t quite know what to do with me.)DSC_0890  Richards was one of Utah’s foremost Relief Society suffrage leaders who attended the World’s Congress and presented as part of the Relief Society session; she was the Ogden Stake Relief Society president, and also a plural wife of Apostle Franklin D. Richards, mother of church attorney Franklin S. Richards, and mother-in-law of Emily S. Richards, who was also a suffrage leader (see above).  This was a spectacular find.  Of course, the various inscriptions led to an investigative conversation with Ardis Parshall, aiming to identify “Mrs. Wallace,” as well as another name in the book, May Packham, who had also signed and dated in 1925. 

A second part of this story has to do with Ardis’s great historical detective skills being put to use—almost at that very hour of discovery—for exploring Mrs. Wallace’s identity and her lifelong friendship with Jane S. Richards, beginning when both families had settled Ogden, Utah.   I will leave that story for a later blog post, either by myself here at JI, or perhaps as a collaboration with Ardis over at Keepa, if she’s inclined.  Imagine it:  an original of The World’s Fair Ecclesiastical History of Utah—signed by one of Mormonism’s preeminent 19th-century female leaders—was found at a small and unpretentious Church consignment store, on a rainy Saturday afternoon in Rexburg, Idaho, while shopping with two small children.  This experience got me to thinking about our historical collectibles– how we acquire them, how we preserve and cherish them, and how we use them. So I will leave this post with these questions for our readers:  What are your own great historical object discoveries, or accidental encounters with memorabilia, rare books, documents, or other finds?   Where are the most unexpected places you have found historical treasures?  And how have these discoveries added to your research, or helped to launch you into new lines of historical investigation?  Perhaps you might just want to top my D.I. story with your own account of a spectacular find at Deseret Industries or some other consignment store.   We would love to hear it!–  Please share your best stories, or comment on mine.

Article filed under Cultural History Gender Material Culture Miscellaneous Reflective Posts Women's History


Comments

  1. I had planned to go to DI somewhere this week, but the trip just got bumped up to today.

    Comment by Saskia T — September 23, 2013 @ 10:46 am

  2. One of my earliest scholarly projects was a biography of Josiah Francis Gibbs, a Utah newspaper editor, a man who was born in Nauvoo, already a 3rd generation Mormon, a missionary, a polygamist … and eventually a virulent anti-Mormon. His book Lights and Shadows of Mormonism, published in 1909 by the Salt Lake Tribune, was something I wanted for my library, but it was always a heavily used book, so the only available copies were badly beat up and rather expensive.

    A few years ago when the Tribune was sold, there was a major overhaul of their headquarters on Main Street, including a digging out of the basement filled with junk stored decades ago. Lo and behold, they found a whole crate of Lights and Shadows, in pristine condition, just as they had been packed away in 1909. The Powers That Were gave a copy to historian Will Bagley, who, knowing of my love for Gibbs, generously passed it on to me.

    I hope you do write about “M.A. Wallace,” Andrea. With minimal effort on our part, “M.A.” went from an inked line to a fully-rounded, admirable person with a life to be remembered and honored, and she ought to be known by more than the two of us.

    Comment by Ardis E. Parshall — September 23, 2013 @ 11:07 am

  3. What a great find, Andrea! As a Richards descendant, I got chills reading Jane’s signature.

    Comment by David G. — September 23, 2013 @ 11:18 am

  4. Wonderful. Thanks, Andrea. I look forward to you and Ardis’s further collaborative research on this!

    Comment by Christopher — September 23, 2013 @ 1:39 pm

  5. Saskia– I would love to go shopping at D.I. with you, understanding that it is a hit-and-miss venture. One day, everything you see is junk, and the next, a jackpot like a World’s Fair book.

    Ardis: Thanks for sharing your story about the Gibbs book. That’s exactly what I am talking about! I’m curious what the Trib did with all those other copies of _Lights and Shadows_. Did they donate or sell them to interested collectors? I certainly hope the books didn’t get thrown away. And yes, one of these days, I will put some touches on the “M.A. Wallace,” using your very generous investigative legwork, and pass it on to our readers.

    David: I didn’t know you were a Richards descendant. There must be thousands of you. And I got similar chills when I saw Jane’s name, without even the privilege of being her relation. P.S. The book is not for sale. 🙂 P.P.S. Have you seen this recent compilation of family history and documents, edited by Kent F. Richards, about the three Richards apostles, Willard, Franklin D., and George F. Richards? It’s at Deseret Book, but I’ve not seen any reviews on it yet.

    Comment by Andrea R-M — September 23, 2013 @ 2:07 pm

  6. I got a pristine copy of the Deseret Alphabet Book of Mormon (partial, from 1st Nephi through Mosiah, I believe.) at a DI in Utah under similar circumstances. This was about twenty five years ago. They weren’t sure what they had, and I have always felt a little uncomfortable about it, so I made a bigger contribution to LDS humanitarian relief with my tithing a few months later.

    Comment by kevinf — September 23, 2013 @ 2:40 pm

  7. What a great and opportune find! I have definitely found some academic books at one of the DIs in Provo that were definitely cheaper than they would have been on amazon or in a bookstore. I always look at their book section now.

    Comment by Natalie R — September 23, 2013 @ 3:02 pm

  8. Enjoyed this post all around, Andrea. I can relate to the joy of discover and the emotion becoming so proximate to the history on which we work.

    Comment by J. Stapley — September 23, 2013 @ 4:32 pm

  9. Very cool. The most interesting thing I’ve found at DI was a pair of leather shoes for $6.

    In our family history a collection of letters was found in a barn loft (early 1800s Louisiana/France correspondence between family members separated by emigration).

    Comment by Edje Jeter — September 23, 2013 @ 5:15 pm

  10. Cool story!

    It’s unfortunate that my six young kids hate the DI because we can never travel past one without daddy making a “quick” stop to look at books!

    My coolest FIND came during Christmas a few years ago when my mom was giving us white elephant gifts and gave me a leather Jos. Smiths Levnetslob signed by my great great grandpa.

    Comment by n8c — September 23, 2013 @ 9:54 pm

  11. …and thanks for posting those pictures! I feel the excitement.

    Comment by n8c — September 23, 2013 @ 9:56 pm

  12. Gracias por compartir con todos nosotros toda esta practica información. Con estos granitos de arena hacemos màs grande la montaña Internet. Enhorabuena por este blog.

    Saludos

    Comment by frio industrial — September 25, 2013 @ 1:18 pm


Series

Recent Comments

Why it's time for the Mormon Church to revisit its diverse past | Wikipedia Editors on Eugenics and the Intellectual: “[…] history of shunning interracial relationships. At points, some of its leaders even flirted with theories of eugenics, or the belief that they could help…”


Tona H on Gem from the Local: “Thanks for responding on our thread, Carol! An honor to have the author join us, truly. Your body of work is an immeasurable contribution to…”


Michelle on Gem from the Local: “I grew up in upstate NY, where Mormon pop culture was pretty much non-existent. I'm not really familiar with the play, but an aunt…”


Ardis on Gem from the Local: “You know you're getting old when your young adult memories are historical artifact. More than once as I've grown older and started seriously wondering whether…”


Carol Lynn Pearson on Gem from the Local: “Hey, thanks for the memories. Glad "My Turn on Earth" lives on, as all of us do in this eternal drama of ours.”


Tona H on Gem from the Local: “Thanks for the memories, Ben and Andrew. It makes me smile that it sustained some entertainment-starved missionaries in Japan, among its many other achievements. Thanks…”

Topics


juvenileinstructor.org