Hark Lay Wales Grave Dedication: Notes and Reflections

By June 10, 2019

On Memorial Day in 2019, 50-60 people gathered to participate in a monument dedication for Hark Lay Wales, a formerly enslaved African American man buried in Utah’s Union Cemetery. Wales, pronounced either like “whales” or “Wallace,” depending upon the person you speak to, lived and died in Utah Territory. He was enslaved by the William Lay family who converted to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Mississippi. Wales entered the Salt Lake Valley in 1847 with the first company of Latter-day Saints.

There is no definitive, published proof that he was a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, though sources have told Juvenile Instructor that information will be forthcoming on centuryofblackmormons.org which suggest Hark may have identified as a Latter-day Saint at some point in his life. For a full overview of Hark’s life, please consult this piece by Amy Tanner Thiriot on Keepapitchinin.

The program preceding the dedication was remarkable for several reasons. First, it was presided over, guided by, and featured nearly all Black speakers, both Latter-day Saint and non-Latter-day Saint. Many of Utah’s and the LDS Church’s best and brightest spoke or sang at the event, including Robert and Alice Faulkner Burch,  Marlin Lynch III, Tekulve Jackson-Vann, Salt Lake City Fire Chief Jeff Thomas, Yahosh Bonner, Utah State Representative Sandra Hollins, David Hollins, Andra Johnson, Nate Byrd, & Byron Williams, and the lone white speaker, Sheri Orton. Robert Burch dedicated the grave through prayer and Melodie Jackson, Garrett Whiting, and Sierra Rose unveiled the headstone.

Another reason the scene was remarkable was the amount of excitement at the event. A definite buzz invigorated the crowd. The project was crowd-funded (but not all the way, you can still donate here) and crowd-supported. As a historian who has spent a long time with African and African American Mormon history, it was a thrill to see so many people as excited and pleased to see Hark remembered and praised for his life and labors. There is a hunger to remember the Latter-day Saint past, especially the Black Latter-day saint past. I’m on the younger side, but I can’t remember a time when popular and academic communities came together to celebrate a single Latter-day Saint on this level—except for the funeral of a Latter-day Saint leader. Remembering Lay’s life, for me, has been both personally and professionally meaningful.

The gravestone next to the Hark Lay Wales marker marks the resting place of Green and Martha Ann Morris Flake, enslaved African American Mormons who gained their freedom sometime after their arrival in the Salt Lake Valley. I bring flowers to their grave every year with my daughters, following the example of Bill Hartley, who brought flowers to Amanda and Samuel Chambers, Black Latter-day Saints whom he wrote about in Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought. When we brought our mums to Union Cemetery, I was thrilled to see flowers already at the grave. In a small planter, in addition to the flowers, was an American flag and a note from the “Flake Family,”  that thanked Martha and Green for their service. This type of language is problematic. The Flakes did not “serve,” they were enslaved. Nineteenth-century Latter-day Saints (and others) used the term “service” and “servants” when they wanted to speak about slave labor and enslaved people in ways that obscured the violence of the slave system. Green and Martha Flake did not “serve” the ancestors of their enslavers out of any sense of love or loyalty. They did so under the threat of violence.

I am sure that the family who left the note meant to offer a conciliatory tribute, but did not know how to speak about their ancestors’ relationship to enslaved people. This feeling of not knowing what to do is understandable. Not knowing what to do often leads to making mistakes around language because we are too embarrassed to ask what to do. But, as Robert Burch told us before the grave dedication, there is a difference between “shame” and “embarrassment.” The first is productive; it leads us to consider the past and what can be done about it. Embarrassment is a form of discomfort that often prevents us from self-reflection or feeling right about asking others about how we can address injustices in the past. 

Two days later, at the dedication of the Wales marker, Utahns and Latter-day Saints repeatedly spoke of how far we have come as communities to identify and commemorate our pioneer settler dead. The note-leaving Flakes, like many Latter-day Saints and westerners, are trying to grapple with the slavery of our past and the racial inequities of our present. So were those gathered at the Wales dedication. In fact, Representative Hollins reminded attendees that “some people feel shame in [Utah’s] past. The shame is in not remembering our past.” Speakers expressed gratitude for those excavating and sharing the past—I join with them, however self-serving that may be.

Viewing the Green and Wales markers next to one another, we see the past, but also how very far Utahns, Latter-day Saints, and historians have to go in commemorating Latter-day Saints and Utahns of Black African descent. Whether scholars and community members choose shame or embarrassment will set the course for how these communities remember Black Latter-day Saints.

Article filed under Miscellaneous


  1. Thanks for posting. The same problematic language between service/slavery is present in the KJV Bible, where slaves are nearly always referred to as “servants.” Like most euphemisms, it’s probably intended to smooth over an uncomfortable topic.

    Comment by The Other Clark — June 10, 2019 @ 12:16 pm

  2. Thank you for the respect you showed our Hark, Green, and Martha as you wrote about them.
    The Afro-American Historical & Genealogical Society of Utah has plans to honor each of our enslaved Black pioneers by placing a stone at their unmarked graves, and we hope the Utah Community will support us as we do so.

    -Alice Faulkner Burch-
    Secretary
    Afro-American Historical & Genealogical Society of Utah

    Comment by Alice Faulkner Burch — June 10, 2019 @ 1:01 pm

  3. If anyone has experience in historical grant-writing and would like to participate in the ongoing group effort to mark the graves of the enslaved, please drop me a line. amyancestorfiles at gmail etc.

    If you don’t mind me adding a link, here’s the fundraising site, with donations still coming!

    https://www.gofundme.com/hark-wales-memorial

    Utah Headstone Design has been wonderful to work with. They went above and beyond on creating and placing the monument, particularly with all the recent rain.

    Comment by Amy T — June 10, 2019 @ 1:38 pm

  4. No man can serve two masters. The greatest among you shall be your servant, and those who exalt themselves will be made low.

    In both of these instances, it’s clear that the Lord was not commenting on the injustice of slavery (hint, it’s a blight on humanity with consequences we suffer from to this day), but rather he was making it clear that those who are relegated to the bottom and either made to serve or choose to serve are the greatest in his sight.

    Stop being offended by everything. I am 100% certain our deceased, enslaved brothers and sisters in many cases would consider what they did “service” — and not out of being brainwashed. They literally saw what they were doing as “serving”, ie doing work for someone else.

    Incidentally, I’ve met very many people outside our church, and inside our church from other cultures who scoff at the idea of “serving” because they feel it demeans them as if they were subservient.

    Comment by lcn — June 11, 2019 @ 4:31 am

  5. This seems like an intentional misreading. Your offense at my raising concerns about the language used to discuss the lives and labor of enslaved people is out of place on this post.

    Comment by J Stuart — June 11, 2019 @ 10:02 am


Leave a Comment

Series

Recent Comments

Jeff T on Roundtable on Quincy Newell's: “Thanks for this, J. I love that you highlighted language and method and thought historiographically, here. Lots to chew on. I can't wait to read…”


J Stuart on 2020 Mormon History Association: “Good point, Quincy! There's no reason to send in an all-male panel. There is plenty of time to network with women.”


Hannah on DH and the Woman's: “Thanks for this great post and run-down of topic modeling. Cheers Jeff!”


Alan Clark on 2020 Mormon History Association: “Hey Ben, I have a topic that might go well with yours. Let's talk. newwavealan@hotmail.com”


Ben S on 2020 Mormon History Association: “I’m going to be submitting something related to the Modernist/Fundamentalist controversy (early 20th century), probably centered around either Joseph Fielding Smith/hermeneutics or the LDS Church…”


Quincy D. Newell on 2020 Mormon History Association: “SLC 2019 was great, and I'm looking forward to Rochester 2020! Let's see if we can make 2020 the YEAR WITHOUT A MANEL--thanks for…”

Topics


juvenileinstructor.org